Whose Responsibility Is Stress?

Perhaps the answer isn't as simple as we sometimes want it to be.

One of the things I find myself talking about more and more in workplace wellbeing is the question of responsibility.

When someone is struggling with stress, whose responsibility is it to do something about it?

The organisation's?

The individual's?

The manager's?

The answer, frustratingly perhaps, is that it depends.

Because stress doesn't always come from one place.

Sometimes work is the problem.

Sometimes life outside work is the problem.

Sometimes it's both.

And sometimes something that starts outside work becomes much harder to manage because work isn't giving someone the space, support or control they need to navigate it.

Where does the organisation's responsibility begin?

Let's start with something important.

Employers have a responsibility to look at the risks that work itself creates or contributes to.

The Health and Safety Executive's Management Standards provide a useful framework for doing exactly that.

They focus on six areas:

Demands – workload, working patterns and the working environment.

Control – how much say people have over how and when they do their work.

Support – the encouragement, resources and support available from managers and colleagues.

Relationships – promoting positive working relationships and preventing behaviours such as bullying and conflict.

Role – whether people understand their role and responsibilities.

Change – how organisational change is communicated and managed.

These aren't simply "nice things for good employers to consider". The HSE states that employers have duties to assess and control risks to employees from work-related stress.

And there is something else within this that I think we sometimes overlook.

Control can be as simple as treating someone like an adult.

It might mean giving someone appropriate flexibility over how they organise their work.

It might mean involving people in decisions that affect them.

It might mean having a conversation rather than immediately imposing a solution.

It might mean asking:

"What would help you manage this?"

rather than assuming we know the answer.

Good organisational practice isn't about removing every source of pressure.

It is about understanding where pressure becomes unreasonable, unsustainable or harmful – and doing something about it.

But what about when the stress isn't caused by work?

This is where things get more complicated.

Someone might be struggling because of bereavement.

A relationship breakdown.

Financial worries.

Caring responsibilities.

A health issue.

A difficult situation with their children.

A major life change.

Or simply because several smaller things have all landed at once.

The organisation may not have caused any of those things.

But that doesn't mean the workplace has no role to play.

Sometimes the right response might be a temporary adjustment.

A conversation about priorities.

Some flexibility.

A change to workload for a short period.

Signposting to appropriate support.

Or simply a manager recognising that this person is having a difficult time and needs a human conversation rather than another performance conversation.

That doesn't mean the employer has to fix someone's personal life.

It means recognising that people don't leave their lives at the door when they arrive at work.

And equally, temporary support doesn't necessarily mean a permanent change.

Sometimes it is simply about helping someone navigate a difficult period and then reviewing what they need as circumstances change.

And then there is individual responsibility.

This is the part of the conversation that can sometimes get lost.

We absolutely should not place the responsibility for organisationally-created stress onto the individual.

But neither should we pretend that individuals have no agency.

We all have some responsibility for noticing what is happening to us.

For recognising our own warning signs.

For communicating when something isn't manageable.

For taking appropriate breaks.

For looking after ourselves.

For accessing support when we need it.

For considering what we might need to change.

And, where possible, for being honest when we are reaching the point where "I'm fine" isn't really true.

There is a difference between personal responsibility and personal blame.

I think that distinction matters enormously.

Someone saying, "I need to do something about how I'm managing this" is very different from an organisation saying, "You need to become more resilient so that this workload doesn't affect you."

Which brings me to resilience.

I get asked to deliver resilience sessions for organisations.

And I genuinely believe they can be valuable.

Understanding our stress response.

Recognising our triggers and early warning signs.

Developing strategies to regulate ourselves.

Learning how to create space between something happening and our response to it.

Building our ability to ask for help.

These are useful skills.

But resilience training cannot compensate for unhealthy working conditions.

The HSE's approach is clear that organisations need to identify and address the underlying causes of work-related stress, rather than simply focusing on the individual. Its guidance also recognises the importance of managers being able to identify and manage stress at organisational, team and individual levels.

Because there is a danger when resilience becomes the answer to everything.

We give people a resilience session...

...and then send them back to unrealistic workloads.

We teach breathing techniques...

...but don't address the toxic relationship with their manager.

We talk about boundaries...

...while rewarding people for working late.

We teach people to recognise stress...

...but don't ask why so many people in the team are experiencing it.

At that point, resilience can become less about helping people cope and more about helping people tolerate something that needs to change.

And that's not what good wellbeing practice should be about.

So perhaps the question isn't "Whose responsibility is stress?"

Perhaps better questions are:

What is within the organisation's control?

What is within the individual's control?

What support is needed right now?

And what needs to change so that the situation doesn't keep repeating itself?

For employers, that might mean looking beyond the wellbeing initiatives and asking some harder questions about work design.

Are demands realistic?

Do people have enough control?

Are managers equipped to support their teams?

Are relationships healthy?

Do people understand what is expected of them?

Is change being managed well?

And are we actually listening when people tell us something isn't working?

For individuals, it might mean asking:

What are my early warning signs?

What am I currently doing that is helping – or making things worse?

What do I need to communicate?

What support could I access?

And what is within my control to change?

The responsibility isn't always equal.

And I think that's important too.

If an organisation has created an unreasonable and harmful working environment, it isn't appropriate to tell the individual that they simply need to be more resilient.

Equally, if someone is going through an incredibly difficult personal situation, it isn't reasonable to expect their employer to solve everything for them.

Shared responsibility doesn't mean equal responsibility.

It means being honest about what each party can influence.

And perhaps most importantly, it means recognising that support and accountability can exist at the same time.

We can support someone who is struggling while still helping them identify what they can do.

We can hold organisations accountable for unhealthy working practices while recognising that individuals have agency.

We can offer flexibility without removing all expectations.

We can have compassion without taking away responsibility.

And we can provide resilience training while still being prepared to ask whether there is anything people are being asked to be resilient to that the organisation should actually be addressing.

Before you ask your people to become more resilient...

Ask yourself what you're asking them to be resilient to.

That might be one of the most important workplace wellbeing questions we can ask.

Next
Next

You Don't Have to Agree With Me, But You Do Have to Respect Me